The best yarn for a tufting gun is 100% New Zealand Wool for professional-grade floor rugs, while high-quality Acrylic (like Red Heart Super Saver) is the best budget-friendly option for beginners and wall art. For the smoothest experience, always use “worsted weight” yarn and double-strand your machine to prevent jamming and ensure a plush finish.
Choosing the best yarn for tufting gun work is the difference between a rug that sheds after a month and a professional piece of art that lasts a lifetime. If you’ve ever had your gun jam or seen your yarn pull right out of the fabric, the material was likely the culprit.
The yarn you choose determines your rug’s texture, durability, and even how smoothly your tufting gun runs. Whether you’re crafting a statement wall hanging or a high-traffic floor rug, the right yarn makes all the difference.
Best Yarn for Tufting Types Compared
When it comes to rug tufting yarn, the three most common types are wool, acrylic, and cotton/blends. Each has its unique characteristics, and your choice will depend on your project’s requirements.
Yarn Comparison Matrix (Durability and Cost)
| Fiber Type | Best Use Case | Durability (Resilience) | Cost/Affordability | Key Properties |
| 1. Wool | Floor Rugs (High-Traffic, Luxury) | Extremely Strong, Bounces Back (Crush Resistant) | Highest Cost (Premium) | Naturally resilient, excellent colorfastness. |
| 2. Acrylic | Wall Art, Practice, Low-Budget Items | Decent, but less resilient than wool; prone to matting under heavy pressure. | Lowest Cost (Budget-Friendly) | Widely available, vibrant colors, simple to clean. |
| 3. Cotton | Decorative Items, Low-Traffic Rugs | Good tensile strength, but lacks resilience (crushes easily). | Moderate Cost | Soft, breathable, eco-conscious choice. |
The Beginner’s Budget Choice: Red Heart Breakdown
If you are just starting out, you don’t need to break the bank on premium wool. Rhody, a veteran tufter, recommends Red Heart Super Saver (Acrylic) as the best entry point. It is widely available and allows you to practice your technique without worrying about the cost of wasted materials.
When budgeting for your first project, keep these two specific options in mind:
- Small Skeins (approx. $4.50): These are perfect for detail work or adding small pops of color to a design without buying more than you need.
- Large Skeins (approx. $9.50): These are significantly more cost-effective for large background areas or “fielding” in your rug.
Pro Tip for Machine Health: Even when using budget-friendly acrylic, always use the “Double Stranding” technique. Threading two strands of worsted weight yarn into your tufting gun ensures the machine feeds the yarn consistently, prevents the needle from snagging, and creates a much plusher final product.
Choosing Your Fiber: The Price vs. Performance Trade-Off
Wool is the top-performing fiber for tufting, but not all wool is equal. Choose based on your project type:
- For High-Traffic Floor Rugs: Wool is the recommended standard. It resists compression, preventing the rug from matting down. For a deep technical dive into wool’s Micron Count and durability standards, consult our specialized guide: Wool Yarn for Rug Tufting.
- For Wall Hangings/Practice: Acrylic is the best choice. It is affordable and perfect for practicing technique and creating decorative pieces.
For a deeper analysis of wool yarn check out our wool yarn technical analysis:
Part II: Key Buying Considerations
Yarn Weight: What You Need to Know
Yarn weight refers to the thickness of the yarn (also known as weight class) and plays a crucial role in the texture and density of your tufted rug. For rug tufting, the most commonly used yarn weights are worsted weight (4) and bulky weight (5).
- Worsted Weight (4): This is the standard, versatile choice for tufting rugs. It often requires threading two strands through the tufting gun for ideal density.
- Bulky Weight (5): Thicker than worsted weight, bulky yarn is ideal for creating plush, dense rugs with a cozy feel.
- Avoid: Avoid lightweight or super bulky yarns, as they can be challenging to work with and may require special guns.
Sourcing and Affordability
Finding high-quality tufting yarn is essential for creating beautiful, long-lasting rugs.
- Premium Sourcing: Specialized tufting suppliers offer wool that is engineered for gun compatibility, consistent twist, and optimal fiber length for clean cutting.
- Budget Options: Blended yarns (wool/acrylic blends) offer a great budget-friendly alternative that retains some of wool’s durability at a lower cost. Look for budget-friendly retailers like LoveCrafts or Amazon for basic acrylic options.
Pro Tip: Get Materials Fast
Your tufting supplies include heavy items like tack strips and adhesive. Skip the standard shipping wait and get started faster:
🚚 Get Fast Delivery for Yarn + Tufting Tools
Save on shipping and get 2-day delivery for all your tufting gear. Try Amazon Prime.
Start Free TrialPart III: Conclusion and Next Steps
Choosing the perfect tufting yarn is a balance of aesthetics and practicality. By prioritizing durability for floor rugs (Wool) and affordability for wall art (Acrylic), you can ensure your project delivers on its promise.
The key is to understand the cost-vs.-performance trade-off for your specific project’s needs.
For a complete, sequential roadmap of the entire tufting journey, see our comprehensive Beginner’s Guide to Rug Tufting.
Choosing the Right Colors
Color selection is where your creativity truly shines! When choosing colors for your rug tufting yarn, consider the following tips:
- Start with a Color Palette: Decide on a color scheme that complements your space or design vision. Use tools like Adobe Color or Pinterest for inspiration.
- Contrast is Key: Use contrasting colors to make your design pop. For example, pair dark colors with light ones to create depth and dimension.
- Neutral Basics: Stock up on neutral colors like white, black, gray, and beige. These are versatile and can be used in almost any project.
- Experiment with Variegated Yarn: Variegated yarns have multiple colors in one strand, creating a unique, blended effect in your rug.
Pro Tips for Buying and Using Tufting Yarn
- Buy Extra Yarn: Always purchase 15% more yarn than you think you’ll need to account for mistakes and practice rows.
- Match Dye Lots: If you’re buying multiple skeins of the same color, ensure they’re from the same dye lot to avoid color inconsistencies.
- Store Yarn Properly: Keep your yarn in a cool, dry place to prevent damage and tangling.
- Experiment with Blends: Try blending different yarn types (e.g., wool and acrylic) to create unique textures and effects.
Tufting Yarn FAQ’S
Acrylic! Try Red Heart Super Saver (under $5).
Yes, but stick to worsted or bulky weight for best results.
For floor rugs, yes. For wall art, try acrylic or wool blends.
Video Tutorials and Additional Resources
To help you get started, check out our video tutorials on rug tufting yarn selection and techniques:
- Check out these informative videos by:
The Rug Maker Co Yarn you can use to make rugs with a tufting gun - Also, That Rug Maker’s short Tufting Rug From Start to Finish
Ready to Tuft?
Choosing the perfect tufting yarn is a blend of art and science. By understanding the different types, weights, and colors available, you can create stunning rugs that reflect your unique style and vision. Whether you’re a beginner starting with acrylic or an experienced tufter experimenting with wool, the right yarn will elevate your projects to the next level.
